Quick Answer
Weber Spirit EX-425C Smart Gas Grill
Top pick — Best overall pick for tech-forward grillers who want guided cooking and smart monitoring without paying a premium price.
See full comparison →Weber Spirit E-435 Gas Grill
Top pick — Best for families or entertainers who need maximum cooking real estate and cook LP at a mid-range price.
See full comparison →Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill (Liquid Propane)
Top pick — Best for LP users who prioritize a side burner and premium build but don't need smart features.
See full comparison →At a Glance
| Product | Score | Price | Key Specs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill | 80 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit SB-E-425 4-Burner Natural Gas Grill | 82 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Natural Gasseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit E-425 Black 4-Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill | 55 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propanecolor: Black |
| Weber Spirit E-425C Gas Grill | 83 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill | 85 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit EX-425C Smart Gas Grill | 90 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit EP-425 4-Burner Natural Gas Grill | 84 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Natural Gasseries: Spirit 400 |
| Weber Spirit E-435 Gas Grill | 87 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
| Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill (Liquid Propane) | 86 | High-end | burners: 4fuel type: Liquid Propaneseries: Spirit 400 |
What to Look For
Burner Count & Cooking Zones
A 4-burner layout lets you run independent heat zones simultaneously — ideal for searing and indirect cooking at once. More burners mean more flexibility, but also more to maintain. Match burner count to how often you cook for larger groups.
Smart Connectivity vs. Manual Control
Some grills in this category offer app-based temperature monitoring, while others rely on analog dials. Smart features add convenience but require a charged device nearby. Choose connectivity only if you'll actively use it during cooks.
Fuel Type: Liquid Propane Advantages
Liquid propane grills heat up faster than charcoal and offer precise flame control. They're portable since tanks are swappable anywhere. Confirm your preferred tank size is compatible before purchasing, as fittings vary by model.
Cooking Surface & Grate Material
Porcelain-enameled cast iron grates retain heat well and resist sticking, making them the preferred choice for searing. Total cooking area — including warming racks — determines how much food you can prepare at once. Prioritize usable primary surface over total advertised area.
Build Quality & Long-Term Value
Stainless steel burners and a porcelain-enameled lid resist rust and extend grill lifespan significantly. Check warranty length on both the burners and the body separately. A longer burner warranty typically signals better construction confidence from the manufacturer.
How We Chose
Grills in the weber spirit e-425 black 4 liquid propane gas grill category were evaluated on cooking versatility, build durability, and feature-to-price balance. We focused on 4-burner propane models that serve households cooking regularly for four or more people. Priority was given to grills with proven heat distribution, accessible replacement parts, and warranties that reflect manufacturer confidence in long-term performance.
How We Chose
Grills in the weber spirit e-425 black 4 liquid propane gas grill category were evaluated on cooking versatility, build durability, and feature-to-price balance. We focused on 4-burner propane models that serve households cooking regularly for four or more people. Priority was given to grills with proven heat distribution, accessible replacement parts, and warranties that reflect manufacturer confidence in long-term performance.
Key Trade-offs
The main tradeoff in this category is between smart features and simplicity. App-connected grills add monitoring convenience but introduce dependency on software updates and wireless connectivity. Buyers who grill frequently and want precise control may prefer analog reliability. Additionally, larger cooking surfaces increase versatility but also increase the physical footprint — measure your outdoor space before committing to a wider cabinet-style unit.
Key Trade-offs
The main tradeoff in this category is between smart features and simplicity. App-connected grills add monitoring convenience but introduce dependency on software updates and wireless connectivity. Buyers who grill frequently and want precise control may prefer analog reliability. Additionally, larger cooking surfaces increase versatility but also increase the physical footprint — measure your outdoor space before committing to a wider cabinet-style unit.
What Matters Most
For most buyers shopping in the weber spirit e-425 black 4 liquid propane gas grill space, burner output consistency and grate quality matter more than headline BTU numbers. High BTU ratings don't guarantee even heat — look for flavorizer bars or heat tents that distribute flame evenly across the cooking surface. Also consider lid thermometer placement and side table workspace, which affect everyday usability more than spec sheets suggest.
What Matters Most
For most buyers shopping in the weber spirit e-425 black 4 liquid propane gas grill space, burner output consistency and grate quality matter more than headline BTU numbers. High BTU ratings don't guarantee even heat — look for flavorizer bars or heat tents that distribute flame evenly across the cooking surface. Also consider lid thermometer placement and side table workspace, which affect everyday usability more than spec sheets suggest.
Our Picks
Weber Spirit EX-425C Smart Gas Grill
Best OverallPros
Cons
Weber Spirit E-435 Gas Grill
Best ValuePros
Cons
Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill (Liquid Propane)
Best PremiumPros
Cons
Who Should Buy What
Weber Spirit EX-425C Smart Gas Grill
Best OverallBest overall pick for tech-forward grillers who want guided cooking and smart monitoring without paying a premium price.
View in Comparison →Weber Spirit E-435 Gas Grill
Best ValueBest for families or entertainers who need maximum cooking real estate and cook LP at a mid-range price.
View in Comparison →Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill (Liquid Propane)
Best PremiumBest for LP users who prioritize a side burner and premium build but don't need smart features.
View in Comparison →Who Should Buy What
Weber Spirit EX-425C Smart Gas Grill
Best OverallBest overall pick for tech-forward grillers who want guided cooking and smart monitoring without paying a premium price.
View in Comparison →Weber Spirit E-435 Gas Grill
Best ValueBest for families or entertainers who need maximum cooking real estate and cook LP at a mid-range price.
View in Comparison →Spirit EP-425 Gas Grill (Liquid Propane)
Best PremiumBest for LP users who prioritize a side burner and premium build but don't need smart features.
View in Comparison →